CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-775010
Zhao Mingli fraud retrial and return of the fine
Date
2018-07-27 — 2019-01-09
Location
Liaoning; Supreme People’s Court Second Circuit
Event Type
Trial
Human Rights Issues
Right to a Fair Trial
Record ID
CNHRA-E-775010
Summary
On January 9, 2019, the Supreme People’s Court announced Zhao’s acquittal. It found neither an intent to appropriate property unlawfully nor fabrication or concealment, and ordered the fine already collected to be returned.[1]
Description
Zhao Mingli was the original defendant in a fraud case arising from commercial dealings. After a conviction on appeal, the Supreme People’s Court took up the case for retrial.[1]
The Supreme People’s Court took up the case on July 27, 2018, assigning it to a panel of its Second Circuit. The final ruling vacated the original appellate judgment and directed the return of the fine already collected.[1]
The retrial judgment examined dispatch notices, accounts, bank credits and witness testimony. The court found that the parties had long collected goods and settled accounts without matching each delivery to a payment. Continuing payments helped support its finding that Zhao lacked an intent to appropriate the goods unlawfully.[2]
The court found no proven deception or concealment, acquitted Zhao, set aside the appellate conviction, and directed return of the fine already collected.[2]
Developments
Original appeal results in conviction
The Anshan Intermediate People’s Court reversed the acquittal and imposed five years in prison and a fine.[2]
Supreme People’s Court orders retrial
The Supreme People’s Court took up the retrial and formed a panel in its Second Circuit.[1]
Date of written retrial judgment
The judgment is dated January 3 and was publicly pronounced on January 9.[2]
Related People
Organizations
No organizations have been added.
Documents
Sources
- [1]
CNHRA-S-775014People’s Court Daily, hosted by the Supreme People’s Court
Evidence location: Retrial judgment, commercial dealings and return of fine
- [2]
CNHRA-S-782012最高人民法院
Evidence location: Findings, reasoning and disposition