CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-775003
Zhang Yuhuan acquitted on retrial
Date
2020-08-04
Location
Jiangxi
Event Type
Trial
Human Rights Issues
Right to a Fair Trial · Right to Liberty and Security
Record ID
CNHRA-E-775003
Summary
On August 4, 2020, the Jiangxi High People’s Court acquitted Zhang on retrial. The Supreme People’s Court website discusses the ruling in the context of evidentiary review and acquittal where the evidence leaves unresolved doubt.[1]
Description
Zhang Yuhuan was convicted of murder, served a lengthy term and sought review by petition.[1]
Jiangxi’s high court acquitted him on August 4, 2020. The Supreme People’s Court’s retrospective presents the case as an example of evidentiary review and acquittal where the original evidence could not support conviction.[1]
Zhang applied for retrial in August 2017. The Jiangxi High Court granted a retrial on March 1, 2019, held a public hearing on July 9, 2020, and delivered judgment on August 4.[2]
Xinhua’s account of the retrial reasons notes that two incriminating statements differed on the location, implements and course of events, and lacked corroboration from physical evidence. No relevant traces had been collected from the site identified at the original trial.[2]
Following acquittal, Zhang filed a separate state compensation application. Jiemian documented the filing and Caixin later reported an award of about 4.96 million yuan.[3][4]
Developments
Jiangxi High Court orders retrial
The court ordered a retrial following Zhang’s petition.[2]
Public retrial hearing
The Jiangxi High Court held a public hearing.[2]
Jiangxi High Court acquits Zhang
On August 4, 2020, the Jiangxi High People’s Court acquitted Zhang on retrial. The Supreme People’s Court website discusses the ruling in the context of evidentiary review and acquittal where the evidence leaves unresolved doubt.[1]
State compensation application filed
Jiemian confirmed the filing with counsel.[3]
Related People
Organizations
No organizations have been added.
Documents
Sources
- [1]
CNHRA-S-775004Supreme People’s Court website
Evidence location: Section on Jiangxi High Court’s August 4, 2020 retrial judgment
- [2]
Evidence location: Retrial order, public hearing and assessment of evidence
- [3]
CNHRA-S-781005界面新闻
Evidence location: Counsel’s account of the filing and the case history
- [4]
CNHRA-S-781021Caixin Global
Evidence location: Compensation amount and length of detention