CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-776006
Yu Huan: Excessive self-defense and revised sentence on appeal
Date
2017-02-17 — 2017-06-23
Location
Liaocheng, Shandong
Event Type
Trial
Human Rights Issues
Right to a Fair Trial · Right to Liberty and Security
Record ID
CNHRA-E-776006
Summary
On appeal, Shandong’s high court found that Yu acted defensively but exceeded necessary limits, and changed his sentence from life imprisonment to five years. Guiding Case 93 uses the ruling to explain how the circumstances affect assessment of self-defense.[1]
Description
Yu Huan used a knife during a debt collection confrontation in Shandong, causing death and injuries.[1]
The Liaocheng court imposed life imprisonment. On appeal the provincial high court considered the collectors’ unlawful conduct and conditions at the scene, found that Yu acted defensively but exceeded the necessary limits, and reduced the sentence to five years. Guiding Case 93 distinguishes the basis for defense from its permissible limits.[1]
Developments
Liaocheng court imposes life sentence
The Liaocheng Intermediate Court ruled on the death and injuries arising from the debt-collection confrontation and sentenced Yu Huan to life for intentional injury.[1]
Appeal finds excessive self-defense and revises sentence
On appeal, Shandong’s high court found that Yu acted defensively but exceeded necessary limits, and changed his sentence from life imprisonment to five years. Guiding Case 93 uses the ruling to explain how the circumstances affect assessment of self-defense.[1]
Related People
Organizations
No organizations have been added.
Documents
Sources
- [1]
CNHRA-S-776009Supreme People’s Court
Evidence location: Guiding Case 93: holdings, facts and appeal disposition