CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-786011
Xia Runying’s sterilization complaint and administrative suit
Date
2012-04-10 — 2015-01-29
Location
Dayu, Jiangxi
Event Type
Coercive Family Planning Measures
Human Rights Issues
Right to Health · Right to Liberty and Security
Record ID
CNHRA-E-786011
Summary
Xia Runying alleged in her complaint that she was taken to the Dayu family-planning clinic on April 10, 2012, and underwent tubal ligation without signing a consent form. Yicai reported that authorities at three levels declined to classify her condition as a surgical complication. On January 7, 2015, she submitted a complaint seeking a declaration of unlawfulness and reversal of the findings. The original judgment has yet to be obtained.[1]
Description
Yicai reported that Xia disputed assessments by county, municipal and provincial authorities in 2013–2014. She submitted an administrative complaint through counsel. The dispute concerned her consent to the procedure and the classification of her subsequent condition.[1]
Voice of America reported in January 2015 that the suit was dismissed and linked the reason to causation of her later health problems. A later Words and Matter account of lawyer Lu Miaoqing’s work describes a jurisdictional ruling. The accounts differ on the procedural disposition and its basis. The original ruling, case number and any later remedy remain unverified.[2][3]
Developments
Administrative complaint submitted
Yicai reported that Xia disputed assessments by county, municipal and provincial authorities in 2013–2014. She submitted an administrative complaint through counsel. The dispute concerned her consent to the procedure and the classification of her subsequent condition.[1]
Public reporting on the court’s disposition
Voice of America reported in January 2015 that the suit was dismissed and linked the reason to causation of her later health problems. A later Words and Matter account of lawyer Lu Miaoqing’s work describes a jurisdictional ruling. The accounts differ on the procedural disposition and its basis. The original ruling, case number and any later remedy remain unverified.[2][3]
Related People
Organizations
No organizations have been added.
Documents
No documents have been added to this record yet.
Sources
- [1]
CNHRA-S-786071Yicai
Evidence location: Complaint, complication assessments and submission of the lawsuit
- [2]
CNHRA-S-786092Voice of America
Evidence location: Xia Runying passages and reported reason for dismissal
- [3]
CNHRA-S-786093Words and Matter
Evidence location: Passage on Lu Miaoqing and Xia Runying