CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-513619
Nie Shubin Case: Execution, Petitions and Acquittal on Retrial
Date
1995-03-15 — 2016-12-14
Location
Shijiazhuang, Hebei; Supreme People’s Court Second Circuit
Event Type
Trial · Sentencing
Human Rights Issues
Right to a Fair Trial · Right to Life
Record ID
CNHRA-E-513619
Summary
Nie Shubin was executed in 1995. After petitions by his family, the Supreme People’s Court publicly announced his acquittal on retrial in 2016.[1]
Description
Nie was convicted in a homicide case in Shijiazhuang, Hebei. The intermediate court imposed the death penalty in March 1995. In April, Hebei’s high court upheld the death sentence for intentional homicide.[1]
In 2005 a defendant in a separate case claimed responsibility, drawing public coverage. Zhang Huanzhi and other relatives petitioned from 2007. The Supreme People’s Court directed Shandong’s high court to review the case in 2014 and took it up for retrial in 2016.[1][2]
The Supreme People’s Court took up the case on June 6, 2016. Its panel reviewed the case file, investigated on site, and heard from the petitioners, their representatives, and the Supreme People’s Procuratorate. Because Nie had been executed, the court conducted the review without an oral hearing and announced the result publicly on December 2.[1][2]
On retrial, the Supreme People’s Court identified insufficient objective evidence linking Nie to the crime, missing interrogation records, missing early witness statements and a missing original attendance record. It concluded that the evidence failed to meet the standard for conviction and announced an acquittal in 2016.[1][2]
On December 14, 2016, Nie’s parents applied for state compensation to the Hebei High People’s Court. The Supreme People’s Court’s later case summary lists death compensation, funeral expenses, compensation for deprivation of Nie’s liberty before his death, compensation for mental distress, and a living allowance for Zhang Huanzhi.[3]
Developments
Execution
The Hebei High People’s Court upheld the death sentence for intentional homicide and approved the execution, which took place on April 27.[1]
Review assigned outside Hebei
The Supreme People’s Court directed the Shandong High Court to review Nie Shubin’s case, assigning scrutiny of the original file to a court outside Hebei.[1]
Supreme People’s Court takes up retrial
Shandong’s high court recommended retrial after its review, and the Supreme People’s Court took up the case.[1]
Retrial judgment issued
The Supreme People’s Court overturned Nie Shubin’s conviction and acquitted him on retrial. This entry records the date the retrial judgment was made.[3]
Acquittal announced
The Supreme People’s Court’s Second Circuit publicly announced that it had vacated the original judgment and acquitted Nie.[1]
Family applies for compensation
Following Nie Shubin’s acquittal on retrial, his parents applied to the Hebei High Court for state compensation in a separate proceeding after the judgment.[3]
Related People
Organizations
No organizations have been added.
Documents
Sources
- [1]
CNHRA-S-513619Xinhua, republished by the Supreme People’s Court
Evidence location: Original judgment, execution, family petitions, review and public announcement.
- [2]
CNHRA-S-513626Supreme People’s Court
Evidence location: Answers on evidentiary problems and compensation procedures explained to Zhang Huanzhi.
- [3]
CNHRA-S-513630Supreme People’s Court
Evidence location: Nie Shubin state compensation case: judgment date, application date and items listed under Hebei compensation decision No. 1 (2016).