CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-775004
Nian Bin: Evidentiary disputes and Fujian High Court ruling
Date
2014-08 — 2014-08-22
Location
Fujian
Event Type
Trial
Human Rights Issues
Right to a Fair Trial · Right to Life
Record ID
CNHRA-E-775004
Summary
The court found unresolved conflicts between his incriminating statements and other evidence, and concluded that the proof fell short of the standard for conviction. The Fujian High People’s Court ultimately acquitted him.[1]
Description
Nian Bin was the defendant in a Fujian poisoning prosecution. An appendix to the Supreme People’s Court work report summarizes the renewed hearings before the Fujian High People’s Court.[1]
The appendix records renewed hearings in July 2013 and June 2014. The court examined whether the statements were corroborated and whether contradictions in the evidence could be resolved.[1]
Contemporary coverage records a remand by the Supreme People’s Court during death-sentence review in 2011. The Fujian High Court continued to hear the case and publicly acquitted Nian on August 22, 2014.[2]
After the acquittal, the Fuzhou Intermediate People’s Court handled state compensation separately. It described awards for loss of liberty and mental harm, including an initial payment at the existing daily rate and a later adjustment.[3]
Developments
Remanded after death-sentence review
Contemporary reporting records a remand for unclear facts and insufficient evidence.[2]
Fujian High Court publicly acquits Nian
The High Court publicly pronounced an acquittal.[2]
Court’s compensation explanation reported
Reporting quotes the Fuzhou court explaining the award and payment arrangements.[3]
Related People
Organizations
No organizations have been added.
Documents
Sources
- [1]
CNHRA-S-775005Supreme People’s Court
Evidence location: Entry on Nian Bin’s poisoning prosecution
- [2]
CNHRA-S-782014中国新闻网
Evidence location: Acquittal and remand after death-sentence review
- [3]
CNHRA-S-782015人民日报
Evidence location: Award components and court’s explanation