CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-777001
Yao Fuxin and Xiao Yunliang: Subversion prosecution after the Liaoyang labor protests
Date
2002-03 — 2003-06-25
Location
Liaoyang, Liaoning
Event Type
Protest · Detention · Trial · Sentencing
Human Rights Issues
Labor Rights · Freedom of Peaceful Assembly · Freedom of Association · Right to a Fair Trial
Record ID
CNHRA-E-777001
Summary
On May 9, 2003, the Liaoyang Intermediate People’s Court convicted Yao of subversion of state power and sentenced him to seven years in prison and three years’ deprivation of political rights. Co-defendant Xiao Yunliang received four years in prison. The Liaoning High People’s Court heard their appeals.[1][2][3]
Description
Yao Fuxin was a workers’ representative in the 2002 collective action in Liaoyang, Liaoning. The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention recorded workers’ concerns about unemployment and wage arrears, along with differing accounts of when he was detained.[1][2][3]
Xiao Yunliang was a workers’ representative in the 2002 Liaoyang collective action. The protests concerned factory management and workers’ treatment. The reproduced defense submissions addressed his labor advocacy and the political activities alleged by prosecutors as distinct factual questions.[1][2]
The Working Group set out both the submitting party’s account and the Chinese government’s response in its 2002 opinion and found Yao’s detention arbitrary. The later domestic judgment and appellate ruling are documented in the reproduced court materials.[3][1]
The defense challenged factual findings and the application of law. The published reproduction contains both defense submissions and the appellate ruling, allowing each party’s position and the court’s disposition to be read in context.[1]
The appellate ruling relied on findings about efforts to organize the China Democracy Party and the workers’ protests in upholding the subversion convictions. Both defendants and their lawyers contested the evidence and alleged intent to subvert. The Liaoning High People’s Court dismissed their appeals on June 25, 2003.[1]
Developments
Liaoyang labor protests and Yao’s detention
The UN opinion records protests over wage arrears and unemployment, and differing dates for Yao’s detention given by the submitting party and the Chinese government.[3]
UN Working Group adopts Opinion No. 15/2002
The Working Group found the deprivation of Yao’s liberty arbitrary. Its opinion predates the Liaoyang court’s judgment.[3]
Liaoyang court hands down first-instance judgment
On May 9, 2003, the Liaoyang Intermediate People’s Court convicted Yao of subversion of state power and sentenced him to seven years in prison and three years’ deprivation of political rights. Co-defendant Xiao Yunliang received four years in prison. The Liaoning High People’s Court heard their appeals.[1][2][3]
Xiao receives a four-year prison sentence
On May 9, 2003, the Liaoyang Intermediate People’s Court convicted Xiao of subversion of state power and sentenced him to four years in prison and two years’ deprivation of political rights. The reproduced appellate ruling records both defendants’ appeals and the Liaoning High People’s Court’s decision to uphold their convictions and sentences.[1][2]
Liaoning High People’s Court dismisses appeals
The reproduced ruling records that the Liaoning High People’s Court dismissed both appeals and upheld the original judgment.[1]
Related People
Organizations
No organizations have been added.
Documents
Sources
- [1]
CNHRA-S-777001Published by Worker Democracy
Evidence location: Xiao’s defense submission and Liaoning appellate ruling No. 317 of 2003
- [2]
CNHRA-S-777003Radio Free Asia
Evidence location: Sentencing coverage and defense counsel’s response
- [3]
CNHRA-S-777002UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, reproduced by the University of Minnesota Human Rights Library
Evidence location: Parties’ accounts, arbitrariness finding and adoption date