CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-513620
Huugjilt Case: Execution, Retrial and State Compensation
Date
1996 — 2014-12-31
Location
Hohhot, Inner Mongolia
Event Type
Trial · Sentencing
Human Rights Issues
Right to a Fair Trial · Right to Life
Record ID
CNHRA-E-513620
Summary
Description
His parents petitioned on grounds that included insufficient evidence and unclear findings of fact. The regional high court reopened the case in 2014. Because the original defendant was deceased, it reviewed the case on the papers, with counsel examining the file and submitting views.[1]
Counsel for the family requested a public hearing and access to materials from a separate case. Given that the original defendant was deceased, the high court decided to review the case on the papers and met with the petitioners and their lawyer.[1]
According to the People’s Court Daily account, Inner Mongolia’s high court found that the methods described in the confessions did not match the autopsy, that blood typing could not identify a unique source for the blood, and that the confessions varied and conflicted with witness statements and autopsy findings. The court found the original findings unclear and the evidence insufficient. The retrial set aside the original judgment and appellate ruling, and court representatives apologized to the family.[1]
A report hosted by the Yunhe County People’s Court records that Li Sanren and Shang Aiyun applied for state compensation on December 25, 2014, and received the written decision on December 31. The listed amounts for death and funeral expenses, deprivation of liberty, and mental distress totaled RMB 2,059,621.40.[2]
Developments
Original conviction and execution
An Inner Mongolia court sentenced Hugjiltu to death in 1996, and he was executed that year. The original findings and evidence were later reviewed on retrial.[1]
Retrial decision served
Court staff served the retrial decision on his father, Li Sanren.[1]
Acquittal announced
The Inner Mongolia High Court announced the retrial result overturning Hugjiltu’s original conviction and acquitting him, and read the judgment to his family.[1]
Parents apply for state compensation
Li Sanren and Shang Aiyun sought compensation following the acquittal on retrial.[2]
Compensation decision received
The decision listed compensation for death and funeral expenses, deprivation of liberty, and mental distress.[2]
Related People
Organizations
No organizations have been added.
Documents
Sources
- [1]
CNHRA-S-513620People’s Court Daily, republished by the Supreme People’s Court
Evidence location: Service of the retrial decision, review on the papers, reasons and family response.
- [2]
CNHRA-S-513621Hosted by Yunhe County People’s Court
Evidence location: Report quoting the compensation decision, covering the December 25 request, December 31 receipt and itemized award.