CNHRA — China Human Rights Archive
← Back to Events Archive

CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-470390

Tang Jingling, Yuan Xinting and Wang Qingying case

唐荆陵、袁新亭与王清营案

Date

2014-05-16

Location

Guangzhou, Guangdong; Tang later held at Sihui Prison

Event Type

Detention · Trial · Sentencing

Human Rights Issues

Freedom of Expression · Right to a Fair Trial

Record ID

CNHRA-E-470390

Summary

Tang Jingling, Yuan Xinting and Wang Qingying were detained on May 16, 2014 over activities including nonviolent civic action, publications and commemorations. Initial disturbance allegations later became inciting subversion charges.[1][2]

Description

Tang Jingling, Yuan Xinting and Wang Qingying pursued civic education and nonviolent initiatives in Guangzhou. Tang continued legal help after his license was not renewed; Yuan had worked as an editor and Wang as a university teacher, both losing their jobs after signing Charter 08. They exchanged and circulated books on grassroots organizing, nonviolent action and peaceful democratization.[6][1]

The three were detained on May 16, 2014, initially for suspected picking quarrels, later facing inciting-subversion allegations. Lawyers raised beatings, coerced testimony and access problems. On November 20 the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention adopted Opinion 49/2014, finding violations involving expression and fair-trial rights and seeking release and compensation.[6][1]

At hearings in June and July 2015, prosecutors cited civic-action books, June Fourth and Lin Zhao commemorations and Charter 08. Defense requests concerned witnesses, complete interrogation records and recusal, with proceedings interrupted. Tang also told the court about denial of outdoor exercise, correspondence and books.[1][2]

On January 29, 2016, Guangzhou’s Intermediate Court imposed five years on Tang, three and a half on Yuan and two and a half on Wang. Wang left prison on November 15 and wrote the following year to thank supporters and seek attention for his co-defendants. Yuan left on November 15, 2017 and entered hospital two days later, sending thanks through friends while relatives reported unreturned identity documents, bank cards and phone.[1][5][3]

Tang remained imprisoned longer. A November 2017 family visit brought news of transfer to Sihui Prison, hospitalization for an ear infection and correspondence difficulties. He left Sihui on April 29, 2019.[3][2]

Developments

Tang Jingling: Detained with Yuan and Wang

Tang, Yuan Xinting and Wang Qingying were detained, initially over a disturbance allegation later changed to inciting subversion. Books, materials and peaceful civic activities were cited in prosecution.[2][1]

Tang Jingling: UN working group finds the detention arbitrary

The UN working group adopted Opinion 49/2014, finding the detention of Tang, Wang Qingying and Yuan Xinting arbitrary, seeking release and compensation and referring torture allegations to the relevant special rapporteur.[6]

Tang Jingling: Joint trial begins

Hearings in June and July involved defense objections over witnesses, files and procedure; Tang described restrictions on exercise, correspondence and books.[1][2]

Three individual sentences

Guangzhou Intermediate Court imposed five years on Tang, three and a half on Yuan and two and a half on Wang for inciting subversion, in a case concerning nonviolent action and publications.[1]

Wang Qingying: Release recorded in personal letter

Wang’s later letter records release that day and his continued requests for attention to imprisoned co-defendants.[5]

Wang Qingying: Writes to supporters and calls attention to those still detained

After release, Wang wrote to thank supporters and relevant United Nations mechanisms, asking for continued attention to his imprisoned co-defendants and other rights defenders. ChinaAid published the letter on March 6.[5]

Yuan Xinting: Released after sentence

Yuan left prison and returned to Guangzhou, sending thanks through friends while unable to meet supporters because of stomach pain and other discomfort.[3]

Yuan Xinting: Sends thanks and an update through friends

Yuan asked friends to relay thanks to supporters, saying he was back in Guangzhou but unable to meet everyone because of stomach pain, other discomfort and family arrangements.[3]

Yuan Xinting: Hospitalized after release

Civil Rights and Livelihood Watch cited family information that Yuan entered a Guangzhou hospital two days after release for stomach disease, bleeding, high blood pressure and other health problems; doctors recommended surgery.[3]

Tang Jingling: Sister learns of hospitalization and correspondence problems

Following a visit, his sister reported that Tang had spent over two weeks in hospital for an ear infection in October, that letters to his father and sister had not arrived, and that medical records could not be copied.[3]

Tang Jingling: Released from Sihui Prison

Tang left Sihui Prison after his term, following family concerns about his health and medical needs.[2]

Related People

Tang Jingling

唐荆陵

CNHRA-P-067377

View Person Record →

Yuan Xinting

袁新亭

CNHRA-P-184395

View Person Record →

Wang Qingying

王清营

CNHRA-P-999188

View Person Record →

Organizations

No organizations have been added.

Documents

No documents have been added to this record yet.

Sources

  1. [1]

    CNHRA-S-604724Amnesty International

    Evidence location: The three sentences, publications and civic campaigns, May 2014 detentions and 2015 hearings. Also: publications, civic activities and 2015 disputes over witnesses and files; Additional passages concerning 2014-05-16, 2015-06, 2016-01-29.

  2. [2]

    CNHRA-S-998636Front Line Defenders

    Evidence location: About; May 16, 2014 detention, January 29, 2016 sentence and April 29, 2019 release; Additional passages concerning 2014-05-16, 2015-06, 2019-04-29.

  3. [3]

    CNHRA-S-115226Civil Rights and Livelihood Watch

    Evidence location: Opening paragraphs: November 15 release and November 17 hospitalization in 2017. Also: his message of thanks, unreturned documents and bank card, and Tang Jingling’s prison transfer.; Additional locator: 2017-11-17 — Hospitalized after release; Additional passages concerning 2017-11-15, 2017-11-16, 2017-11-17, 2017-11-18.

  4. [4]

    CNHRA-S-860501Front Line Defenders

    Evidence location: Profile on teaching, Charter 08 and nonviolent civic action.

  5. [5]

    CNHRA-S-370356ChinaAid

    Evidence location: Personal letter expressly recording release on November 15, 2016.; Additional locator: 2017-03-04 — Writes to supporters and calls attention to those still detained; Additional passages concerning 2016-11-15, 2017-03-04.

  6. [6]

    CNHRA-S-421746UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention

    Evidence location: Paras. 4–12: careers, advocacy and detention; paras. 23–28: analysis and disposition; adopted November 20, 2014; Additional passages concerning 2014-11-20. Reference notes: Career and early activity details appear in the source submission at paras. 4–12; the working group’s findings are at paras. 23–28. Adopted November 20, 2014 and distributed February 11, 2015.

Record ID: CNHRA-E-470390