CNHRA — China Human Rights Archive
← Back to Events Archive

CNHRA EVENT RECORD · CNHRA-E-775022

Deng Yujiao: First-instance conviction and exemption from punishment

邓玉娇案一审与免予刑事处罚

Date

2009-06-16

Location

Badong, Hubei

Event Type

Trial

Human Rights Issues

Women's Rights · Right to a Fair Trial

Record ID

CNHRA-E-775022

Summary

On June 16, 2009, the Badong County court found her guilty of intentional injury, held that her defensive conduct exceeded necessary limits, and exempted her from criminal punishment. The exemption formed part of a judgment that included a finding of guilt.[1]

Description

Deng Yujiao was the defendant in a criminal case in Badong, Hubei. The CCTV account of the ruling describes the incident and the court’s characterization of her conduct.[1]

According to the court findings carried by CCTV, Deng rejected a demand to accompany a man in bathing and was obstructed when she tried to leave. The court considered the conduct at the scene, the injuries and the limits of self-defense in its ruling.[1]

Southern Weekly reports that the Badong County court opened the hearing that morning and delivered judgment in court. It describes written testimony submitted by both sides, the absence of live witnesses, and the media admitted to observe.[2]

The court found Deng guilty of intentional injury and cited excessive self-defense, diminished criminal responsibility and voluntary surrender in exempting her from punishment. These were the reasons reported from the judgment.[2][1]

Developments

Court exempts Deng from criminal punishment

On June 16, 2009, the Badong County court found her guilty of intentional injury, held that her defensive conduct exceeded necessary limits, and exempted her from criminal punishment. The exemption formed part of a judgment that included a finding of guilt.[1]

Morning hearing and written evidence

The trial report records a morning hearing and the submission of written testimony by both sides.[2]

Related People

Deng Yujiao

邓玉娇

CNHRA-P-775036

View Person Record →

Organizations

No organizations have been added.

Documents

Sources

  1. [1]

    CNHRA-S-775046CCTV website

    Evidence location: Trial court findings and reasons for exemption from punishment

  2. [2]

    CNHRA-S-781019南方周末

    Evidence location: Morning hearing, submission of testimony and judgment in court

Record ID: CNHRA-E-775022